Wednesday, June 2, 2010

MasterBlah - add rampant commercialism to a good TV show and stir

Masterchef.

An international phenomenon that was developed by the BBC and first started in the UK in 1990 (yes...20 years ago). It has gone through various incarnations in the UK over this period (some obvious" Celebrity MasterChef, some less so: Junior MasterChef for kids up to 16), and more recently it has travelled the globe, with series now being produced in France, Greece (on a limited budget I'm sure) and of course in Australia.

Here it has been a HUGE success, most surprisingly to me to children, who apparently love the food, the cooking and especially Matt Preston's looks of delight and disgust.

The first series was interesting, fresh in its approach (the judges rarely took a hard line and regularly complimented the contestants), well paced and cast well. The fact that a really boring mum won it and has not been seen often since (while the very annoying runner up has her own TV show now on ABC, which is hilarious to watch only for seeing the likes of Neil Perry play second fiddle to "Poh the really annoying runner up" through clenched teeth only raises it in my estimation.

So how does one go about completely stuffing it up? Well the producers of the show have managed to do so already and this is how.

1. Casting wuss bags.

The casting of any TV show is always tricky. You do need the right mix of people to make reasonable entertainment, but this year they have cast a bunch of nuffys who shed floods of tears at the drop of a hat because their food dream is on the line. Some of these people are 21. If you want to have a food dream at 21, go and get an apprenticeship rather than answering a casting call.

What I find interesting is that the eliminated contestants all talk about how their food dream is not dead and they will own a restaurant soon. Then they do the update, and they are back doing their regular jobs.

They might have had a dream - but it has nothing to do with food.

2. Over calling it on a regular basis

"You are the best 18 amateur cooks in Australia".

Umm..sorry..no, you are the 18 cooks we decided would make good television out of a pool of people who wanted to be on television. You are either good eye candy (Fiona), prone to drama and tears (Carrie), have a sob story (Adele, with a son who has some kind of tragic circumstance that other mothers will relate too) or intriguing (the rock dude who fidgets so much you wonder what drugs he did when he was a rock dude).

"C'mon guys, you are now fighting for your life"

Ummm..actually no, the little girl with multiple myeloma in the cancer ward is fighting for her life.

You are just making television. Not always well.

3. Casting people who buy cookbooks rather than can cook.

I don't know about anyone else out there, but when Matt Preston introduces whichever celeb demi god chef is going to come on the show for a challenge or for a pressure test or whatever, invariably I have no idea who they are.

Up until recently, I had no idea who Tony Bilson was, I have never heard of Phillipa Sibley and the guy from Movida who lost is known to me only as "the guy from Movida who lost".

It seems as though these contestants either have a cheat sheet, spend ALL their money on eating out (and then study the menu as to who the chef was) or buy the cookbooks these chefs invariably produce - because they know all about them, their restaurants and their Swiss bank account numbers.

Regardless, if you are going to call someone one of the best 18 amateur cooks in Australia (see above), you'd hope they would have cooked their own pasta before.

When the pasta challenge came on, some of them admitted to not ever having done that. Incredible.

4. Perpetuating the Gordon Ramsay Myth.

If you are to believe MasterChef, when times get tough and tight, what a chef does is yell and scream at the top of thier voice and use motivational phrases like "C'mon guys...it's time to boom boom". Oh, I forgot the obligatory "yeah?" at the end of the sentence. (And why do Chefs always make a statement and finish with the question? Are they expecting someone to say.."actually..no..You're wrong"?)

If George or Gary make one more motivational football like statement and bang their hands together, or wave them about like they are in a rave party without the glow stick I am seriously going to turn off.

When I have worked in kitchens, or have occasionally scored a table in the kitchen (either by design or mistake by the 12 year old taking my booking), the chefs are more intent on boinking the waitress and/or the apprentice (usually at the same time), on the phone to their amphetamine dealer or uttering the phrase "3 second rule!"

I have never heard them yell. Not once.

5. Truck out the same "philosophy"

I think I might have mentioned this before - but every local, international celeb chef, cook, chief bottle washer they get on the show says the following thing:

"My food philosophy is to source the absolute best and freshest ingredients and prepare the food with respect and love and cook it simply"

Rick Stein, seafood master and established pants man, said this and proceeded to ask the contestants to prepare a seafood platter that took 2 hours to make, had 15 different sea foods in it, with a gazillion different processes including a cooking some seafood a la Nage (which I will bet my left nut that 90% of the audience, and contestants, had NEVER heard of until that moment).

Simple cooking my rump (medium rare, with truffle butter).

To cook food well it also helps if you have been professionally trained over an extensive period of time and do it day in day out as your career with access to all the whiz bang equipment.

6. Allowing the judges to get fat.

Gary Meaghan, George Column-alphabet and Matt Preston have all blown out and look more like 3 teletubbies than anything else. When Matt Preston dons the pink pants and the cravat, he looks like someone thought preparing a flamingo for foie gras would be a good idea.

There are cardiologists out there who are flicking through their travel guides with glee when they see those three.

The question remains, how long will it be until MasterChef meets the Biggest Loser?

7. Location location location

Last night, fidgety rock dude was reading his recipe from a Telsta Hub.

Apparently all the good chefs source their food (sea urchins included) from Coles (not withstanding that some of the previous challenges revealed that some of this Coles supplied food is out of date and unusable - retake anyone?).

Matt Preston was hands and knees on the floor the other night wiping up salmon roe with his Handy Ultra. (It is unknown whether he stayed in that position long enough so the rest of them could watch a movie that was projected onto his backside.)

To all that product placement I say - Puh-lease! Some marketers would argue that since I can recall these things they have done their job. What they won't and don't get is that I recall them in a negative fashion.

So yeah, I might remember, but any publicity is not always good publicity.

When I went to coles the other day - there was a MasterChef magazine. Just so I can get the recipes which are available on the Masterchef website, which I can view off my Telstra hub, which I can probably take to coles in case I forget my list, to the my masterchef magazine.

8. Flogging the horse until it dies.

I can't remember how often the first series was on. I am pretty sure it was not an hour and a half every night (30 mins on Thursday and nothing on Saturday to be fair), but commiting to MasterChef each week soaks up an awful lot of my limited television watching time. I have a child who also needs to be fed and put to sleep, as well as a wife I need to talk to occasionally. 7+ hours a week of watching 3 fat blokes run around in a contrived manner is too much for me to handle. And while I am here, trucking out a celebrity version just after the original aired signalled early this horse was going to be glue pretty quickly.

Alas poor Masterchef, the first series was grouse.

Until next time

Max.

No comments:

Post a Comment